Imagine a Six Nations opener without Maro Itoje starting for England. It’s almost unthinkable, right? But that’s exactly what’s happening this Saturday, as England’s talismanic captain takes a seat on the bench for their clash against Wales—a decision that’s as bold as it is emotional. This marks the first time in nearly seven years that England will kick off a Six Nations match without Itoje on the field, and it’s a move that’s already sparking conversations among fans and pundits alike.
The reason behind this surprising call? Itoje’s recent personal tragedy. After missing the start of England’s preparations in Girona to attend his mother Florence’s funeral in Nigeria, the 2025 British and Irish Lions captain opened up about his grief. ‘It’s been difficult, to be honest,’ he told the Sunday Times. ‘It’s been challenging on both the professional and personal front. It’s just the paradox of life.’ And here’s where it gets even more poignant: Itoje has been an ever-present force for England in the Six Nations since 2020, playing every single minute of 30 consecutive matches. His absence from the starting lineup is not just tactical—it’s a testament to the human side of the sport.
But here’s where it gets controversial: Is this the right call by coach Steve Borthwick? While Borthwick insists it’s best for Itoje to start from the bench, some fans are questioning whether this decision underestimates his resilience or overlooks his on-field impact. Borthwick, however, is confident. ‘I think he is going to have a massive impact,’ he told Rugby Union Weekly. ‘The crowd will show their appreciation with a big roar when Maro comes on.’ And this is the part most people miss—Borthwick’s emphasis on the team’s emotional bond. He believes the current squad’s relationships run deeper than those in his playing days, a point that’s both heartwarming and thought-provoking.
Speaking of relationships, hooker Jamie George—Itoje’s Saracens teammate and former England captain—will lead the side from the start. George, whose own mother passed away during England’s 2024 campaign, has vowed that the squad will rally around Itoje. It’s a powerful reminder of the team’s unity, but it also raises a question: Can this emotional support translate into on-field success?
Elsewhere in Borthwick’s lineup, the Northampton duo of Fraser Dingwall and Tommy Freeman have secured their spots in a hotly contested midfield battle. Freeman’s transition from winger to outside centre has been nothing short of impressive, highlighted by his hat-trick in Northampton’s December win over Bath. But what’s really intriguing is Borthwick’s faith in their club-level chemistry. Will their partnership at Northampton translate to international dominance? Only time will tell.
And this is the part most people miss: Borthwick’s selection isn’t just about individual talent—it’s about building a cohesive unit. Take the back three, for example. Henry Arundell, making his first start since the 2023 World Cup, joins Freddie Steward and Immanuel Feyi-Waboso in a trio designed to counter Wales’ expected kicking bombardment. It’s a strategic move, but it also highlights Borthwick’s trust in players who’ve proven themselves domestically.
Wales, under new coach Steve Tandy, are predicted to take to the skies with a barrage of contestable kicks. ‘We expect Wales to bring a kicking game, so we’ll need to be accurate in how we respond,’ Borthwick said. But here’s the real question: Can England’s backline—a mix of experience and youthful energy—rise to the challenge?
As the 2026 Guinness Six Nations kicks off, one thing is clear: this tournament is about more than just rugby. It’s about resilience, unity, and the ability to adapt under pressure. But here’s the controversial question: Is Borthwick’s lineup a masterstroke or a risky gamble? Let us know your thoughts in the comments—we’d love to hear your take on this bold new era for England rugby.
